A fan remake of Tiny Speck’s Glitch · Credits · Privacy

Chats

Game Balance Thread

General

Started by Goldminermac · 1 reply

  1. Goldminermac

    I thought I'd make a thread for general game balance suggestions and feedback. I understand disagreements on some of these points for those who are more interested in a casual game experience, but I personally enjoy having a bit of a grind and making in game resources scarce and valuable for a better long-term playing experience, and the game seems a little stilted right now in terms of balance.

    1: Crops, trees, and rocks produce far too many resources when harvested, A wood tree giving 60 planks from one harvest, or one field of onions providing half a dozen stacks from about 12 seeds is a bit too much. My biggest issue is with rocks which have been completely devalued, as mining is fast, produces much more rocks per mine, and rocks regenerate almost instantly after being mined. I personally recommend returning work times, crop growth times, and harvest yields to their much lower original game baselines to give these resources value again and make skills that boost work speed more meaningful. I also recommend greatly increasing the time it takes for rocks to respawn after being fully mined (my recommendation is once per game day, but that may be too extreme) to make rocks scarce and encourage traveling to find new rocks to make the world meaningful and spread-out players instead of allowing infinite mining from one street.

    2: Quest rewards, and level-up rewards flood the player with imagination, favor, and currants too quickly, removing most of the early game challenge. Imagination specifically is given out in very large amounts too early on. I found that I had a basically endless supply of money and more imagination than I could use from the very beginning. Reducing rewards on early milestones in exchange for increasing rewards on later ones is my recommendation.

    3: Skill learning times are too fast, especially early on, which devalues early skills. Extremely fast completion of skills initially also leads to an unmanageable buildup of quests, and an over-abundance of currants, imagination, favor, and energy from the completion of said quests. My recommendation is to greatly increase the time it takes to learn skills and decrease the rate at which skill learning time increases to compensate for this. Each skill should feel meaningful and players should need to think about what skill they want to prioritize and have time to become familiar with it before the next one unlocks.

    If anybody has any feedback or other observations please add them here.

  2. AeghorStaff

    Thanks for writing this up, Goldminermac. Some of it is on purpose: crops grow about 10 times faster than in Glitch, mining is about 8 times faster and rocks come back about 11 times faster, because there are a few dozen of us on the streets instead of thousands, and a world built for thousands feels empty and slow at 2012 speed. That isn't settled for good. Right now I'm measuring how currants, imagination and xp actually come in during play, and the next round of economy work sets the rates from those numbers. Your three points (yields, early rewards, skill times) go into it. Keep adding to the thread: specifics like the 60 planks help.

    Austin

Sign in to post. Reading is open to everyone; posting needs your Groddle Afternoon player account.

Sign in New player